Search engine optimisation (SEO) can feel overwhelming—especially when you see lists of hundreds or even thousands of keywords you could target. But here’s a truth the pros know: chasing too many keywords at once is one of the fastest ways to waste time, money, and energy.
At BlueSoap, we’ve helped countless Australian businesses improve their visibility online. And time and again, we’ve seen that narrowing your focus to a few carefully chosen keyword groupings delivers better rankings, higher conversions, and more sustainable growth. Let’s explore why.
1. Quality Beats Quantity Every Time
Imagine you’re planning a wedding. Would you rather hire a florist who specialises in exquisite wedding bouquets or one who dabbles in a hundred unrelated crafts? The same logic applies to SEO. Search engines like Google favour websites that demonstrate depth and authority in specific topics—not websites that spread themselves thin across dozens of loosely related keywords.
By focusing on a small set of keyword groupings, you can create detailed, helpful content that answers every question a potential customer might have. Instead of ten shallow articles that barely scratch the surface, you produce a few outstanding pieces that truly stand out.
This depth signals to Google that your site deserves to rank. It also provides a better experience for your visitors—helping them trust your expertise and nudging them toward becoming customers.
2. Build Topical Authority and Trust
Google’s algorithm has become much smarter over the years. It no longer just counts keywords; it looks for topical authority—how thoroughly your website covers a specific subject area.
Let’s say your business sells forklift equipment. If you focus on related keyword clusters—like “forklift fork extensions,” “shipping container ramps,” and “forklift work platforms”—you can create interconnected content that shows Google you’re an expert in material handling solutions.
On the other hand, if you also try to rank for unrelated keywords like “coffee machines” or “pool cleaning tips,” your site sends mixed signals. Google won’t know what your website is really about, and your rankings will suffer.
Building authority within a clear, narrow set of keyword clusters makes your site a trusted resource. Over time, this trust leads to stronger rankings across all the related terms you care about. At BlueSoap’s SEO Services, we specialise in choosing the right keyword clusters.
3. Attract the Right Traffic—Not Just Any Traffic
More traffic isn’t always better. The goal isn’t just visitors—it’s visitors who are ready to engage, enquire, or buy.
When you target fewer, more relevant keyword groups, the people who find you are far more likely to need what you offer. This means better engagement, longer time on site, and—most importantly—higher conversion rates.
For example, a florist who focuses on “wedding flowers Sydney” and “bridal bouquet delivery” will draw in brides and wedding planners—exactly the right audience. Targeting dozens of unrelated phrases may bring more clicks, but many of those visitors won’t be looking for your services.
4. Use Your Resources Wisely
SEO isn’t just about writing content. It involves keyword research, technical optimisation, backlink building, analytics, and ongoing updates. Each of these tasks takes time and effort.
If you try to rank for too many keywords, you risk stretching your resources so thin that nothing gets done properly. But with a narrower focus, you can put your energy into producing exceptional content and outreach for the keywords that matter most. The result? Better rankings, faster. Smart keyword targeting works even better when paired with a fast, responsive site—our Website Design Services can help.
5. Easier to Track and Improve
When you’re monitoring hundreds of keywords, it’s hard to see what’s working and what’s not. A smaller, more focused keyword strategy makes reporting and decision-making much simpler.
You can clearly track progress, understand which topics are driving traffic and sales, and quickly adjust your strategy if needed. This level of control is nearly impossible when your efforts are spread across too many targets.
6. Create a Clearer Brand Message
SEO isn’t just about algorithms—it’s about people. If your website tries to be about everything, potential customers may struggle to understand your core offer. Focusing on fewer keyword groupings keeps your messaging sharp and consistent.
When visitors see your brand consistently associated with specific topics or solutions, they’ll start to trust you as the go-to expert. That trust is what turns search traffic into paying customers.
7. How to Choose the Right Keyword Groups
Choosing the best keyword groupings takes thought, but here are a few quick tips:
- Understand Your Audience: What are your ideal customers searching for?
- Check Search Intent: Are they looking for information, products, or services?
- Evaluate Competition: Look for opportunities where search volume is healthy but competition isn’t overwhelming.
- Use Related Clusters: Group similar keywords together so your content can rank for multiple related terms at once.
At BlueSoap, we specialise in keyword research and competitive analysis to identify the phrases that can deliver the most impact for your business.
8. Real-World Example
One of our Sydney-based clients initially targeted dozens of unrelated keyword groups. They generated some traffic, but conversions were low. After narrowing their focus to just three keyword clusters and creating in-depth content around those topics, their organic traffic became far more qualified. Within six months, they doubled their enquiry rate—without increasing their content budget.
9. The BlueSoap Advantage
At BlueSoap, we don’t just do SEO—we build strategies that make sense for your business. Our Australian-based team works closely with you to understand your goals, choose the right keyword groupings, and create content that resonates with your audience.
Unlike agencies that hand you off to offshore support or ask you to log support tickets, we pride ourselves on personal service and direct communication. You’ll work with real SEO experts who are invested in your success.
10. Ready to Stop Spreading Yourself Thin?
If you’ve been trying to chase too many keywords and aren’t seeing results, it’s time to rethink your strategy. Focusing on fewer keyword groupings can give your business the authority, trust, and conversions you’re aiming for—without wasting time or budget.
Call BlueSoap today or visit our SEO Services page to start building a smarter, more effective SEO strategy. Let’s focus on the keywords that matter and get your website ranking where it belongs—on top.
Explore more tips on our Digital Marketing Blog